i would like to comment on some of the new trails popping up around the mundaring and kalamunda areas. i would like to comment on the single track mess that some one has cut to bi pass the whore, that horrible hill near pickering brooke. the track is being called the whore no more by most so i will call it that. this single track winds down the hill at a stupid angle that is too steep for extended use. this trail will turn into a mess come winter from all the braking ruts at the stupidly tight corners that some one has cut into the hill. also there are broken off tree stumps and other sharp and annoying stuff sticking out in the trail. this trail although fun at time is pretty crap. its as steep as a down hill track but has next to no flow in it. if anyone is to build a track they should avoid making mostly crap trails. they should look at the IMBA
website or even bettter buy the IMBA book on trail building. i would have to say that who ever built this trail did not do either.
all the worlds best trails flow, they dont have you stop starting the entire length like the whore no more. this trail is pretty disapointing!
the white tape trail is a better trail but still lacks flow in the top area near gunjin. the rest being not to bad.
so please think before building trails, and maybe look into learing to correct way.
__________________________
Why?
Why would someone put in a track to bypass the whore?
I mean, you might as well take a 4x4.
The whole point is that it is a specific well known challange (which i haven't manadged to do yet!!!!)
As for poorly built track - the test of time be upon them. Many tracks that we now ride have survived this test.
As for the White - remember - it was built to be ridden UP (I know the guy that designed it - and I am assured that HARD DRUGS were not used in the design process), down is just an option - It dosen't all have to slick singles, sometime tight is an extra challange.
-------------------------------------------
I may be slow but I an't dumb
-------------------------------------------
Bloody hell.
I thought the Whore No More was made to be ridden UP not DOWN?
If you want to go up, you now have the option of a technical singletrack climb. If you want to go down, you can still bomb the Whore at 90 million miles an hour. Until the corner - Aiieee!!
Up!
Yeh use it as a climb, and all your gripes go away.
stumpcrasher wrote: so
so please think before building trails, and maybe look into learing to correct way.
Perhaps stumpcrasher could build us a better trail instead of moaning about the result of someone else's time and effort.
Oh, and maybe learing to spell.
tested
I've heard the Whore-Bypass being called "The Hoe" at times.
It's getting ridden in quite well. Crappy trails usually get abandoned- clearly people like this one.
The Hoe
"the Hoe" sounds like a techmical uphill.
"The Whore no more" sounds like an interesting down hill.
I would like to ride stumpcrashers trails to see how well they flow.
If people dont like the trail, They wont ride it. Time will tell.
Stumpcrasher I challenge you to ride Pile rd.
By the way how did you get the name "Stumpcrasher"
Awsome track both ways if ya
Awsome track both ways if ya dont like it go the other way
stumpcrasher wrote: also
also there are broken off tree stumps and other sharp and annoying stuff sticking out in the trail.
Bother, perhaps one could send out the gardener in advance to trim those nasty annoyances and make diddums ride so much more pleasant.
poorly built trails?
Well,everyone is entitled to their opinion.I was involved in the building of this trail as were many other enthusiastic riders who by popular demand built the "Hoe'.I will be goig on the Trail Building Course at the end of the month,out of interest and to complete my passion for mountain biking and trail building.Trail building is time consuming and does require certain skills and a bit of a passion for what you are doing.I do it to put back in to mountain biking what I get out of it,loads of fun which I often get to share with my riding mates.I accept criticism if it is constructive,but I think that in this case I don't really see what the problem is,the trail is still quite new so let's give it a winter to "bed in".The response to the "Hoe" has been has been very good as it has been to all the other trails we have created,maybe you should come and ride with us and explain what does not suit you with the "Hoe".Regards,FastFreddie.
Kudos to you FastFred - all
Kudos to you FastFred - all your recent trail activity in the region has held up well, and offers much more interesting alternatives to the traditional fireroad sections on the "old school" trail loop.
I don't see any significant fall line sections in Whore No More, no major trees were cut to build it, the trail isn't cut against the camber of the hill and it retains a great flow both ways despite what some may think. I firmly believe it's going to hold up well over time. The switches might chew out a bit, but show me a technical singletrack through WA laterite where that doesn't happen.
Essentially an excellent addition to the singletrack in the area, now all I have to do is stop breaking parts of my bike so I can ride it more regularly.
Cheers for your hard work.
"Make mine a blue one" said Mr Squirrell!
I agree ... thanks for your good work
Interesting topic-
White Tag - one of the best down hill single tracks in Perth IMO - there are plently of folks who can make that trail flow.
The Hoe - it will evolve in to a great down hill and tech uphill.
If you don't like the trails DON"T RIDE THEM!
Can't believe someone would take the time to diss someone elses hard work especially from a ride point of view (maybe a fair call if you were talking about a legal or enviro perspective).
See you all out there- smiling after a ripping run of the white tag or legs burning after climbing the hoe - BTW who has cleaned the hoe?
Clean Hoe
I assume you mean ridden the Hoe without dabbing? Little Timmy Bennett, Ian and I have. I assume the Dark Snake and Toby have. There'd be a few more out there I'm sure. Cobby would have yesterday but his bike mechanic is rubbish so his rear derailleur wouldn't work proper and stuff.
I think the climb will cut up over the winter, I guess we'll just have to use our granny rings then.
Jimmy
See the happy moron
he doesnt give a damn,
I wish I were a moron
my god perhaps I am.
.
Hey Stumpcrasher. Welcome to the forum. You sure know how to stir up a bit of controversy on your first post.
As for the Hoe, I think it is a pretty good trail. There are a few steepish sections near the top that may need realignment when the rains start, but it certainly seems a popular alternative to the Whore. I am sure over time this trail will evolve into an awesome track, just like the White tag.
.
now now fellas, cant keep flogging a dead horse.
Assuming its his first and now his last post, or an alias, for example jimmy creating another user name to vent his frustrations.
Trail Building Course??
I will be goig on the Trail Building Course at the end of the month,out of interest and to complete my passion for mountain biking and trail building.Trail building is time consuming and does require certain skills and a bit of a passion for what you are doing.
Where does one find out about trail building courses that you mention? I would be interested in what is involved depending on when, where etc.
It is amazing that on the
It is amazing that on the front page of the website there is a BIG post that says" Trail building Workshop" If you choose to read under that you will find all the info you need. I won't say anymore just so you can explore the website.
People are welcome to come on the Thursday night and Saturday if they can't make the Friday.
if you dont like the trail
if you dont like the trail dont ride it.
i rode the mundaring loop circuit the other day even that was bad and this was done by the mundaring shire.
at the start near mundaring it is full of sand and gravel. even some dh bits was washed away creating big ditches, but who cares
i did not like it so i will not ride it again and i will ride some where else.
ouch
i have not replied to previous posts because i didnt want to get into a tit for tat argument about who can or cant ride, or who can build the better trails. so i guess we can disscuss what we all think about trail building.
the point i was trying to make is that the track might not last the winter because of the braking ruts and tight corners. we should be building trails that are sustainable and last a long time. i think the trail will suffer from erosion over winter. so this erosion will affect the surrounding bush which i think is bad. if the corners where widened ( among other fixes) and made to last, the track might last as it has an out slope on the track so some water may wash off the trail.
i did not set out to stir the pot i was worked up after riding the track,so posted this because i just care for the enviro and want the trails built to last.
That may be the case friend,
That may be the case friend, but consider a few things - how much effort have you put in to developing our trail network in the last 12 to 18 months? Have you even been riding a mountainbike that long? (I have no idea as I don't have a clue who you are)
No-one who has posted has turned this topic into an argument about who is the better rider. By my reckoning, all the posts have had a similar theme and that is - perhaps you shouldn't be so quick to criticise someone elses incredibly dedicated hard work, when there is precious little evidence of you having done the same.
As the ink on the back of my arm says " be the change you wish to see". Something for you to ponder over.
i dont no!
bitches, ride the fuck out of the trail. run some 2.7's through there that ought to chew it up (hehehehehehehe)! luv ya cobby.BRETTLZ
Brettles you signwriting
Brettles you signwriting clown!
How are yo Bro? Haven't spoken to you in ages. Still ripping it up mate?
Hoe Hoe Hoe
Congrats stumpcrasher. You have given the Hoe a lot of publicity.
Now I want to ride it, to see for myself. Where is it?
I invite you to ride Wals track. Its how real trails should be.
.
I would certainly agree that Wal's track is a mighty fine bit of single track. As is the whole pile road network. I love that stuff and tip my hat to the folk that built it.
I can't say that the Hoe is quite that level, yet. However it is much better than beating yourself up riding that whore.
Frontpage
It is amazing that on the front page of the website there is a BIG post that says" Trail building Workshop" If you choose to read under that you will find all the info you need. I won't say anymore just so you can explore the website.
Mate - not everyone enters the site from the front door - ever hear of a shortcut straight to the meaty stuff (forums)? Unfortunately in this case I missed some meat - my loss. Anyway I asked the question, and had my head bitten off - I got the info and went to the presentation. If I hadn't asked the question, I would still be none the wiser.
Anyway to cut the cr@p, I have ridden the hoe (uphill only) and as tough as it is is, I take my hat off to those who toiled and think it will age to become a great piece of single track.
pile road is great
Congrats stumpcrasher. You have given the Hoe a lot of publicity.
Now I want to ride it, to see for myself. Where is it?
I invite you to ride Wals track. Its how real trails should be.
hi wal, i have riden pile road quite a few times as its my brothers local track. quite a nice track. and will be going back soon!!
as for where it is hopefuly some one who is better at directions can guide you there. even after 5 years+ of riding aound there i still struggle with directions.
certainly wasn't trying to
certainly wasn't trying to bite your head off netorious77.
Cobby you have made some pretty interesting observations. IF you do a job half arsed does that mean it is better than someone who hasn't done the job but has an understanding of what is required? It sounds to me that STumpcrasher understands and is trying to achieve the same thing as the rest of us. The Hoe has some potential and to this stage is a great climb. much better than the whore. But as I climbed it I made the same observations. That is it needs better corners with some consideration to water run off and braking ruts.
comparing apples with pears
... IF you do a job half arsed does that mean it is better than someone who hasn't done the job...
This is an excellent point (question), JC.
Having been fortunate enough to see the Hoe being built at various stages before "completion", I must say that the vegetation density, landforms and topographies of all those Pile Rd trails (very good indeed) and The Hoe are completely different, and the challenges that the builders of the Hoe faced would have been very different to those met by any of the Pile Rd trail builders. So, I don't think that anyone can say with any authority: "it should be built like the Pile Rd trails".
fair cop
how true this is.
The hoe's bottom 3rd
Originally the hoe was intended to be ridden both ways, and you can see this as a more gentle gradient in the lower third of the track.
It would be great to be able to keep this easier gradient for the whole track, but in reality the bush is so littered with fallen trees and super dense vegetation (tick infested) that sometimes the only option is to redirect the track into a more aggressive gradient. Even the white tag has some of these issues, but less so because of the less dense bush for most of the track.
I would like to thank all who built the Hoe (you know who you are) because I never have to do the whore again, up or down.
ps Who ever built the Pink Tag ??? Thanks and Great Job, it must have sucked raking all those pine needles up.
Happy riding Pete.
Trails is just Trails
Any chance of mentioning skill, fitness level and riding style (DH XC etc.) when passing comment on a trail experience. It would help planning rides to suit needs and create less predjudice on judgements made of any trail, adding positively to the MTB community.
Learning the proper skills and getting increased fitness on suitable trails can also lead to greater interest in participation in the competetive aspect of the sport which grows the sport and the club.
And for the sake of parity, give the up and down versions of the trail.
P.S Pile Road and the "Wal's Track" part of it are a top ride that i enjoy when visiting family in Bunbury. Nice work Wal hope to see you out there sometime.
Gez
XC Rider
Sport A Class middle of the pack.
I suppose it is pointless to
I suppose it is pointless to mention that the trail is illegal and theoretically should never have been built in the first place! How long before DEC gets aggressive on shutting down such trails will be interesting to see but imagine it will be influenced by the quality of the trails from an environmental point of view. To that end, the trail faries need to build sustainably, even if that means a less "challenging" trail, otherwise DEC will just see it as hack work and in the long run it will be detrimental to MTBing. I'm not confident, however, that most people can see beyond their own preferences and think about long term impacts.
Trails development
Well said Bron.
With respect to your last comment, I can understand the motivation for trail building, despite the legality issues. When there are no alternatives, well, what are you going to do?
However, things ARE changing. The recent coming together of trail 'pirates' and DEC at the IMBA workshop was a great positive. DEC have shown that they have understood that there is a need for MTB trails, and that they are committing time, effort and money into trails development. It is great to see this positive attitude toward our needs from land managers.
Therefore, I think PMBC should take on the responsibility of raising awareness of the issues relating to trails building in WA, to try to adjust the 'outsider' attitude that may have developed out there amongst trail builders. There is a lot of energy and enthusiasm among the mountain biking community and we should be attempting to direct this in a manner which will not be detrimental to long term aims and relationships with land managers.
We can, and will (if we do it right), build a fun, sustainable and legal trail network in WA.
I happy with that! Just let
I happy with that! Just let me know when and where... :)
Hear hear!
Therefore, I think PMBC should take on the responsibility of raising awareness of the issues relating to trails building in WA, to try to adjust the 'outsider' attitude that may have developed out there amongst trail builders. There is a lot of energy and enthusiasm among the mountain biking community and we should be attempting to direct this in a manner which will not be detrimental to long term aims and relationships with land managers.
We can, and will (if we do it right), build a fun, sustainable and legal trail network in WA.
Hear, hear!
Perhaps a summary of the discussions from the Trail Building Seminar/Workshops could be posted on the PMBC site to help fill everyone in on the Big Picture as it currently stands?
Indeed.
Great suggestion. We should have some info to share this week.
really shit trail or really shit rider?
Hi "stumpcrasher" have you been out to the Whore No More (WNM) lately? Probably not.... since you hate it so much.
Well any way if you did go and check it out you would actually see that the trail has stood the test of winter even with the excess amount of rain we have had.
If you knew anything about building trails.... (which I would say you don't since it sounds like you work for DEC they way you talk) ... you would know that a trail is like a fine wine, it only gets better with age.
I have riden WNM many times on the weekends rain hail & shine and have most time bumped into people riding the trail. So I would say if that amount of people are riding it then it can't be that bad. Maybe you should just stick to the fire brakes.
So to all those people out there that liked WNM ... keep your eyes peeled.
--------------------------------
I belive in Trail fairys
What's Happening
Hey Maxfacta
You mention above about Dec understanding our needs and putting in an effort to get a trail network. Has anything happened yet?
alltrax things are happening
alltrax things are happening but not at warp speed. This time of year isn't the time to build either. Come October November we should see some things happening on the 4x at the Goatfarm (a public design meeting will be held 7th September).
And the Kalamunda Circuit will hopefully progress between October and April.
Time to build
This time of year isn't the time to build either.
I totally disagree! Now is thie time to build trails. You can make well cut trails, berms and jumps with the moist soil and then they have time over spring and summer to dry out and become strong and permanent trail features. And not some loose bull dust track.
--------------------------------
I belive in Trail fairys
Trail Building
How many people here turned up to the DEC sponsored Trail Building work shop with they guy from the US. Also how many have turned up to the organised busy bees This would show who should be building with APPROVED sustainability in mind and not their own opinions of how trails should be made and Maintained if at all HATS OFF TO TRACKMAN FOR ALL HIS EFFORTS IN DEALING WITH DEC This should get a few bites HAHA
The Rolling Stone Gathers No Moss
Dirt Munchers & Gravel Grinders
Hats of to any and all souls brave enough to swing a shovel and throw a fire rake around the scrub :)
I've got a saying if you want to criticize a trail do it with a shovel.
As to those who built the trail (champions that you are) there are always plenty of knockers and only a handful of crew with big enough balls to get out and do it. Keep up the good work!!!
What's happening
Thanks for the info John.
In the past I have heard straight from the horses mouth (DEC) that it isn't viable to build trails through the dryer months as the soil (gravel ) will not compact and they have used that reason for trail building not progressing, also the heat factor through summer would eliminate some of the available days between October and April.
Most of us realise that it is a lack of DECS resources that is holding up the progress for new trail networks. With the State election looming do you think it is time for some lobbying to be done?
Cheers
Alltrax
What is wrong with DEC
While DEC are becoming a thorn in mountain bikers side in Perth, Scotland is stepping it up an creating some world class trails with Northshore that is more then 1 foot off the ground.
check out: http://www.7stanes.gov.uk/
maybe we should all move too Scotland!
--------------------------------
I belive in Trail fairys
It is DEC who want us to
It is DEC who want us to build in October and November. It is them that gets to decide these things. we definitely won't be building during DEcember to March becasue of the dry weather.
AS for 7Stanes that will be an example of trail management and promotion that I think will be taken on by different areas in WA. Julie Cartner from 7 Stanes visited Perth and was impressed and impressive.
excited
The 7stanes look pretty amazing. It's got me all a quivering and excited. It would certainly be pretty special to be part of the grass roots development to get similar sanctioned networks of trails here. Hopefully DEC and the mountain bike community can pull together to make this a reality.
I will keep checking here to see the latest news from John and the other dedicated mtb crew. If there is trail building sessions then I am keen to help.
Goat Farm
The Goat Farm is our seedling 7stanes - sort of a Proof of Concept, I guess you could say - especially from the land manager's perspective. With that in mind, keep your eyes peeled for an announcement about a major trails maintenance day up at the Goat Farm. It's extremely important to show that we can look after the infrastructure that we have.
Search